Lookalike Audiences Guide 2026: Finding Your Next Best Customers at Scale

Key Takeaways

• Lookalike audiences find new customers who share traits with your existing customers
• 1% lookalikes are highly targeted; 3-5% lookalikes offer better scale
• Broad targeting shows 113% ROAS vs. 76% for lookalikes in some tests
• Advantage+ AI targeting is challenging traditional lookalikes
• Combine lookalikes with interest targeting for precision + scale

What Are Lookalike Audiences?

A lookalike audience helps you find new customers who are likely to be interested in your business because they share similar traits with your existing customers.

How They Work

You provide a seed audience — Customer list, website visitors, purchasers

Platform analyzes traits — Demographics, behaviors, interests

AI finds similar users — People with matching characteristics

You choose audience size — From 1% (most similar) to 10% (broader reach)

Seed Audience Options

Seed Type	Quality	Use When

Purchasers	Highest	Finding more buyers
High-value customers	Highest	Targeting premium segments
Email subscribers	High	Building awareness
Website visitors	Medium	Top-of-funnel expansion
App users	High	App promotion
Video viewers	Medium	Engagement campaigns

Lookalike Size Strategy

The 1-10% Spectrum

Size	Similarity	Reach	Best For

1%	Highest	Smallest	High-ticket products, precision targeting
2-3%	High	Medium	Balanced approach, most campaigns
4-5%	Medium	Large	Scale with quality
6-10%	Lower	Largest	Maximum reach, brand awareness

Scaling Strategy

Start narrow, expand based on performance:

Test 1% — Establish baseline performance

Scale to 3% — If 1% performs well

Test 5% — For more volume

Compare to broad — See if broad targeting beats lookalikes

> "Typically, advertisers start with targeting a 1% lookalike audience. To enhance your campaign's reach without saturating your audience, consider increasing this to between 3% and 5%."

Lookalikes vs. Broad Targeting in 2026

Here's the honest debate happening in 2026:

The Broad Targeting Case

Metric	Broad Targeting	Lookalike Targeting

Average ROAS	113%	76%
Average CTR	~1%	~1%
Average CPM	Lower	45% higher

When Lookalikes Still Win

• Limited budget — Need to focus spend on precise audience
• High-ticket products — Quality over quantity
• Niche markets — Specific customer profiles
• Cold start — Before platforms learn your audience
• B2B campaigns — Professional targeting precision

When Broad Wins

• Large budgets — Let AI find the best audiences
• E-commerce — High volume, lower prices
• Established pixel data — Platform knows your buyers
• Advantage+ campaigns — AI handles optimization

Meta Advantage+ vs. Lookalikes

How Advantage+ Changes Things

> "Meta's Advantage+ targeting is an advanced AI-driven solution that automatically adjusts your audience targeting to maximize results. Unlike manual targeting, Advantage+ dynamically refines who sees your ads based on real-time engagement and conversion data."

When to Use Each

Use Advantage+	Use Lookalikes

Established pixel with 50+ conversions/week	New campaigns, limited data
High budget ($5K+/month)	Budget-conscious targeting
E-commerce with broad appeal	Niche products, specific audiences
Shopping campaigns	Lead generation

Hybrid Approach

Best practice in 2026:

Start with lookalikes for new campaigns

Use Advantage+ "suggestions" feature

Combine lookalike seed with Advantage+ expansion

Let AI expand beyond initial audience if results improve

Creating High-Quality Lookalikes

Step 1: Build Strong Seed Audiences

Best seed sources:

• Customer email lists (hash before upload)
• Purchase custom audiences (last 180 days)
• Website conversion events via pixel
• High-value customer segments from CRM

Step 2: Segment Your Seeds

Don't just use "all customers." Create specific seeds:

• High-LTV customers — Top 20% by revenue
• Repeat purchasers — 2+ orders
• Recent converters — Last 30-60 days
• Specific product buyers — For product-specific campaigns

Step 3: Technical Setup

Step 4: Layer with Interests

For even better precision:

• Create 1-3% lookalike
• Add relevant interest targeting
• Exclude existing customers
• Exclude recent website visitors (avoid overlap with retargeting)

Funnel Placement for Lookalikes

Top of Funnel (Awareness)

• Audience: 5-10% lookalikes
• Objective: Reach, video views
• Creative: Brand intro, problem awareness
• Budget: 20-30% of total spend

Middle of Funnel (Consideration)

• Audience: 1-3% lookalikes
• Objective: Traffic, engagement
• Creative: Product benefits, social proof
• Budget: 30-40% of total spend

Bottom of Funnel (Conversion)

• Audience: Custom audiences, not lookalikes
• Objective: Conversions
• Creative: Offers, urgency
• Budget: 30-40% of total spend

Platform-Specific Lookalikes

Meta (Facebook/Instagram)

Setup:

Go to Audiences in Ads Manager

Create Audience → Lookalike Audience

Select seed source

Choose location and audience size

Create and use in campaigns

Unique features:

• Value-based lookalikes (prioritize high-LTV)
• Multi-country lookalikes
• Audience overlap checker

Google Ads

Similar Audiences (legacy):

• Based on remarketing lists
• Auto-created from customer match

Customer Match:

• Upload customer lists
• Google finds similar users
• Works across Search, Shopping, YouTube

LinkedIn

Lookalike Audiences:

• Based on Matched Audiences
• Company or contact list seeds
• Best for B2B targeting

Common Mistakes to Avoid

Mistake 1: Using Too Small a Seed

Problem: Seed audience < 1,000 people Fix: Build larger seed before creating lookalike

Mistake 2: Never Refreshing Seeds

Problem: Using same seed for 6+ months Fix: Update seed quarterly with fresh customers

Mistake 3: Not Excluding Existing Customers

Problem: Paying to reach current customers Fix: Always exclude purchasers and email list

Mistake 4: Only Testing One Size

Problem: Assuming 1% is always best Fix: Test 1%, 3%, and 5% simultaneously

Mistake 5: Ignoring Audience Overlap

Problem: Multiple lookalikes compete against each other Fix: Check overlap, consolidate similar audiences

Measuring Lookalike Performance

Key Metrics

Metric	What to Watch	Action Threshold

CPM	Rising CPMs signal saturation	>50% increase
CTR	Declining CTR shows fatigue	<0.8%
CVR	Conversion rate stability	<1% for e-commerce
Frequency	Audience exhaustion	>3 per week
ROAS	Bottom line efficiency	Below target

Testing Framework

Run controlled tests:

Split test lookalike vs. broad

Test different seed audiences

Test different sizes (1% vs. 3% vs. 5%)

Measure at 7-day and 28-day windows

The Bottom Line

Effective lookalike strategy in 2026 requires:

Quality seeds — Start with your best customers

Right sizing — Match size to campaign goals

Test vs. broad — Don't assume lookalikes always win

Hybrid approach — Combine with Advantage+ when appropriate

Regular refresh — Update seeds quarterly

> "Facebook's Lookalike Audiences remain a valuable tool for advertisers aiming to expand their reach. However, it is advisable to use other targeting methods to ensure your campaigns remain effective."

---

AdBid helps you analyze audience performance across platforms. See which targeting strategies drive the best results. Start analyzing.